Three reviews below, but first, a rant: Why is this country still sexist when it comes to women and baking/cooking? I brought home-made cookies to our softball game yesterday, but before I had time to announce their presence I had to take the field for batting practice. Someone on the sideline noticed the batch of chocolate chip cookies and immediately asked our first basemen, the only woman on the team, whether she brought them. Obviously, no guy would be competent enough to bake cookies.
I readily acknowledge that with some attribute differences (e.g., height, longevity, strength, endurance) exist on average between the sexes. But I can't for the life of me figure out what part of pre-heating an oven, measuring ingredients, using a mixer, and setting an oven timer people believe women are predisposed to. And if you want to go down the "society pushes women to cook more" route, I'd like to point out that the feminist revolution ebbed and waned over 30 years ago, well before anyone on my softball team was born.
And this strange bias seems to afflict both men and women, as last year's TMG bake-off's demonstrated. Several female colleagues commented how great it was that so many of us men entered dishes in the bake-off. Yes, it was such a struggle to overcome our Y-chromosome handicap.
Whatever the cause of this misperception, I'd just like to go on the record strongly opposing the belief that only women bake. In fact, I have a chocolate cheesecake in the fridge right now. Oh, and while we're disposing of myths, let me add that our first baseman has the highest batting average on the team :)
Below are reivews of A Praire Home Companion, the New York Museum of Natural History, and the new Pride and Prejudice movie.
A Prairie Home Companion
I saw PHC with Samidh and Monica's Kevin in NYC last weekend. My reaction to the movie was exactly the same reaction I have when I listen to the radio show: it's not as funny as I expect it to be. Surprisingly, the movie has a semblance of a plot, though not a particularly good one, but at least it holds the disparate radio show acts together. I found it odd that Guy Noir was the main character; perhaps if Kevin Kline has made the role believable I wouldn't have minded as much. The music is great, and the cast is all-star, though this movie doesn't ask too much of their talents. If you're a die-hard PHC fan, I don't have to tell you to go see this movie; if you're not, I'd estimate that PHC is worth $6 of your $10 movie ticket.
The New York Museum of Natural History
I just felt the need to say that the most interactive part of this museum is the automated ticket machine in the front lobby. Naomi and I toured the museum during my aforementioned trip into the city. And while she was perfectly content with the exhibits, I must say that I've been spoiled by the newfangled museums in DC such as the Air and Space Museum, the Spy Museum, and the Science Center. Those places know how to make learning more than staring at tableaus. Perhaps my expectations were too high, as many people I know gave the museum rave reviews. And while it covered a wide range of topics from African garments to the Big Bang, the presentation left me underwhelmed.
I can only hope that the British Museum, which I'll be visiting in a couple weeks (!), will be much better. Of course seeing the Rosetta Stone will probably trump all other considerations.
Pride and Prejudice
The movie stays reasonably true to the book--the important differences in this version manifest themselves through the characters. From best to worst (via the five daughter rating system).
Mr Collins (5/5 daughters): The old black-and-white version (as well as the A&E version according to Janeite) depicts the role of Mr Collins as an over-the-top, Oscar Wildesque character. In these older versions (and to an extent, in the book), Mr Collins acts so improrietously that one finds it difficult to understand why Mr Collins doesn't realize that he's making a fool of himself. However, director Joe Wright envisions an understated Mr Collins, in which Mr Collins tries so hard to fit it that he--simultaneously--believes he is successful and, in reality, misses the mark to an embarassing degree.
Mr Bennett (4/5 daughters): Donald Sutherland plays the part of Mr Bennet sublimely, with the correct mix of detachment and concern. As a side note, I find it odd how Mr Sutherland seemingly hasn't aged since playing the role of the pot-loving professor in over 25 years ago animal house.
Mr Bingley (3/5 daughters): He is portrayed as a dope, which I guess makes being tricked by his sister and best friend more believable. And I don't mind when guys who go for the prettiest girl over the cleverest are depicted in a negative light. Simon Woods' acting, though, was a bit strained.
Jane, Lydia, Mrs Bennet, Kitty: Nothing stood out.
Mary (2/5 daughters): On the plus side, Mary is protrayed as quite the nerd. She doesn't get many mentions in the text, so it was nice to see them at least make her character one-dimensional. But, I give this portrayal negative marks for personal reasons -- Mary-the-nerd is looked upon with scorn and ridicule, and rather than ignoring her detractors, she breaks down and sobs. Now what kind of role model is that for young girls who want to be the smartest instead of the prettiest? To an extent this interaction is a result of the time period the book is written in, but the filmmaker updated other parts of the story (made it a kissing book!)--I guess us nerds are not worthy enough for renovation.
Charlotte Lucas (1/5 daughters): Am i the only one who thinks that Charlotte's a lesbian? Apparently not, but that didn't stop this cinematic version from portraying Charlotte as a craven, pathetic loser who marries beneath her because she sees herself as too old and too plain for anyone reasonable. Did they even read the Charlotte Lucas scene?! Charlotte marries for pragmatic and stoic reasons, not because she gives into her own fears. As Janeite noted, they even gave one of Lizzy's lines to Charlotte just to make Miss Lucas seem more superficial and agrestic. Bastards.
I seem to have left out Lizzy and Darcy...well, they're minor characters anyway ;)